The importance of good data and independent scrutiny
If you only read the mainstream news you’d be forgiven for thinking that the effectiveness of the vaccines in protecting against severe illness and death is unequivocally positive. You also wouldn’t see much (if any) data on vaccine damage or vaccine-related mortality.
For example, I noticed yesterday’s Times headline “Doctors’ anger as unjabbed fill emergency beds”. They quote the latest figures (only up to July, unfortunately) which states that three-quarters of the critical care beds taken up by COVID patients were occupied by those not vaccinated. However, if we look more widely at all hospital COVID admissions and COVID deaths by vaccination status, we see a very different picture. As ‘Dr No’ in his blog points out, looking at the Government’s own data – the UKHSA’s latest COVID-19 vaccine surveillance report we see that COVID hospital admissions (these reports don’t single out ICU admissions specifically) and COVID deaths are much higher in the vaccinated group. This is not at all surprising, because much of the adult population is now vaccinated.
So how can it be – this great disparity between what is seen in ICU compared to COVID admissions and COVID deaths generally?
I don’t know, and it is likely to be a number of factors. But it does show that we need to analyse the data more thoughtfully and in the broader context to help make sense of it, and we shouldn’t be led to kneejerk conclusions based on headlines.
Luckily there are a number of people trying to make sense of the information that’s available. I thought I’d point you in the direction of a few:
Prof Norman Fenton, Mathematician, Queen Mary University
- His website and blog: https://www.normanfenton.com/
- YouTube:
- Interviewed by Majid Nawaz, LBC Radio 4 Dec 2021 (8 mins)
- Analysing Covid vaccine efficiency and safety statistics (18 Nov 21, 26 mins)
Blogger: ‘el gato malo’
- All cause deaths and vaccination status (26 Sep 21)
- Are covid vaccines working? (take 2, corrected data) (9 Sep 21)
Blogger ‘Dr No’
- All Cause Mortality, Again (1 Dec 21)
- The Needle and the Damage Done (10 Nov 21)
- Montezuma’s Revenge (13 Oct 21)
- Covid Vaccine Mortality (27 Sep 21)
HART Group
- It gets worse before it gets better (29 Nov 21)
- What is real-world vaccine effectiveness? (23 Nov 21)
Some of the blog posts are quite detailed and data heavy, so if you have limited time or ‘headspace’, I suggest you listen to one of the interviews with Norman Fenton as he explains some of the main issues very clearly.






