The ‘competing’ theory to Pasteur’s germ theory
The germ theory is the accepted modern-day view of infectious disease that states that the presence of microorganisms (bacteria, viruses, fungi, etc.) can lead to ill health in the form of infections. So far, so good.
However, there is also the terrain theory, which is less well known. Its detractors focus on the most extreme form of this idea that states that microorganisms have little or no role in disease – and that the state of a person’s health and functioning of their physiological environment (i.e., terrain) is everything – the microbes merely being attracted to the ‘diseased’ tissue.
Of course, the truth takes in both these ideas. Germs can cause ill health. But, aside from the virulence of a pathogen, one of the main factors that determines how successfully that microorganism becomes established in a system, and thus whether and to what degree someone gets ill from exposure to it, is … the person’s immune system and their state of health. The state of the ‘terrain’ does, indeed, have a profound effect.
Focusing on ‘what’s in here’ vs. ‘what’s out there’
With regard to COVID, for example, given what we know about the importance of an optimised state of health, having the whole focus on vaccination as the single solution for all, is rather naïve, not to mention worrying. Not only will Mother Nature continually out-manouver vaccines through the production of new genetic variants, but it’s similarly oversimplistic thinking that led to our current problem of antibiotic-resistant bacteria through the heavy-handed use of pharmaceuticals. While vaccinating large chunks of the population may or may not affect how the virus mutates, a whole host of side-effects and risks are now apparent for these vaccines, and we do not yet have data on long-term effects. While I would not wish to be without conventional medications, we must use them with discernment.
Solely focusing on ‘killing the enemy’ rather than properly ‘fortifying the castle’, will always have huge limitations. Modern medicine needs to fall out of love with the idea of a single ‘magic bullet’. Disease is multifactorial, and its solution needs to be too. Raising your level of health has to be at the heart of looking after yourself in an infectious world.
Let’s focus on improving the ‘terrain’!






