Mind–body medicine and the risks of being a football fan …
Some interesting research caught my eye when reading Dr. Malcolm Kendrick’s book The Great Cholesterol Con, about the impact of professional football results on deaths of men from heart disease, and I was reminded of this after Sunday’s Euro 2020 final.
If you don’t believe that the emotions can profoundly impact health, read on.
Kendrick cites three studies. The first, A matter of life and death: population mortality and football results, looked at patterns of mortality in four populations in the north of England in relation to football games involving the major local teams. They found that over a five year period, male deaths increased by 30% on the days the local professional football team lost at home. No significant difference was found in women.
This tallies with the results of another paper, Admissions for myocardial infarction and World Cup football: database survey, which showed risk of admission for acute myocardial infarction increased in England by 25% on 30 June 1998 (the day England lost to Argentina in a penalty shoot-out) and the following two days.
Not surprisingly, there appears to be a protective effect for the fans when a team wins, as documented in Lower myocardial infarction mortality in French men the day France won the 1998 World Cup of football.
While the underlying disease process that leads to deaths from cardiovascular causes takes years to develop, these authors recognise that intense emotions such as anger and disappointment can act as a trigger for an acute event and that elation can be protective. In fact, Kendrick cites this work in a much broader context, and discusses the role of different forms of chronic and acute stresses (psychological and physical) in heart disease. He particularly identifies the chronic stress of ‘social dislocation’ as a major factor at the population level, and looks at heart disease rates in a number of populations around the world. By ‘social dislocation’ he means the impact of societal upheaval, disrupted family and social structures, loss or change of economic/social status, etc., that can be identified in certain populations at certain times, for example those that undergo mass migration or a major ideological change in their country.
While we can’t avoid the highs and lows of day-to-day emotions, I think the take home message is that chronic emotional stress is an important risk factor in cardiovascular disease. Taking time off for relaxation and fun, ensuring we have supportive social networks and developing good stress-reduction techniques is vital.






